AEO Analytics Setup: Tracking AI Search Performance

Knowing which metrics to track means little without systems capturing that data. AEO analytics setup requires configuring existing tools for AI traffic, implementing custom tracking where standard tools fall short, and building dashboards that surface actionable insights. This guide walks through the technical setup process.

Google Analytics 4 Configuration

GA4 captures AI referral traffic when configured properly.

Identify AI Traffic Sources

Configure traffic source recognition for major AI platforms.

Key referral sources to track:

AI Platform	Referral Patterns	How to Identify
ChatGPT	chat.openai.com, chatgpt.com	Direct referral
Perplexity	perplexity.ai	Direct referral
Claude	claude.ai	Direct referral
Google AI	google.com (with AI parameters)	UTM or behavior patterns
Bing Copilot	bing.com/chat	Referral path analysis

Create Custom Channel Groupings

Separate AI traffic from organic search in GA4.

Setup steps:

1. Navigate to Admin > Data Display > Channel Groups
2. Create new channel group: "AI Search"
3. Add source conditions for each AI platform
4. Set priority above organic search grouping

Example channel rules:

Channel: AI Search
Conditions (OR):
- Source contains "chat.openai"
- Source contains "perplexity"
- Source contains "claude.ai"
- Source equals "chatgpt.com"

Build AI Traffic Segments

Create reusable segments for ongoing analysis.

Recommended segments:

Segment Name	Definition	Purpose
All AI Traffic	Combined AI sources	Total AI visibility
ChatGPT Traffic	chat.openai.com only	Platform-specific analysis
Perplexity Traffic	perplexity.ai only	Platform comparison
AI Converters	AI traffic + conversion	ROI measurement

Custom Event Tracking

Standard GA4 events don't capture AEO-specific interactions.

Track Content Citations

Monitor when AI-optimized content receives visits.

Implementation approach:

1. Tag pages with AEO optimization status using dataLayer
2. Create custom event for AEO page views
3. Compare performance: optimized vs. non-optimized

DataLayer implementation:

// Add to AEO-optimized pages
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
dataLayer.push({
  'event': 'aeo_page_view',
  'aeo_status': 'optimized',
  'content_type': 'faq',
  'schema_types': ['FAQPage', 'Article']
});

Monitor Engagement Signals

Track deeper engagement from AI referrals.

Custom events to implement:

Event	Trigger	Value
aeo_scroll_depth	75% scroll on AI traffic	Engagement quality
aeo_time_threshold	2+ minutes from AI source	Content relevance
aeo_internal_click	Navigation from AI landing	Journey continuation
aeo_conversion	Goal completion from AI	Business impact

Search Console Integration

Connect Search Console data to understand how AI visibility affects traditional search.

Set Up API Access

Pull Search Console data programmatically for correlation analysis.

Required setup:

1. Enable Search Console API in Google Cloud Console
2. Create service account with appropriate permissions
3. Connect to data warehouse or spreadsheet

Track Branded Search Impact

Monitor whether AI citations drive branded search increases.

Correlation tracking approach:

• Pull weekly branded search impressions and clicks
• Compare trends against AI citation frequency
• Calculate correlation coefficients monthly

Third-Party AEO Tracking Tools

Dedicated tools fill gaps in standard analytics.

AI Visibility Monitoring Platforms

Several platforms specialize in tracking AI mentions and citations.

Tool categories:

Category	Function	Setup Requirement
Brand monitoring	Track mentions across AI platforms	API integration or manual queries
Citation tracking	Monitor source attribution	Regular platform queries
Competitive analysis	Compare visibility vs. competitors	Platform subscription

Manual Tracking Protocols

When automated tools aren't available, structured manual tracking works.

Weekly manual audit process:

1. Query 20-30 priority keywords across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude
2. Document citation presence (yes/no/partial)
3. Record competitor citations for same queries
4. Calculate week-over-week changes

Tracking spreadsheet structure:

Keyword	Platform	Cited	Position	Competitors	Date
[query]	ChatGPT	Yes	1st source	competitor.com	[date]
[query]	Perplexity	No	-	other.com	[date]

Dashboard Construction

Build dashboards that surface actionable AEO insights.

Essential Dashboard Views

Create views answering key questions.

Recommended dashboard structure:

AEO Performance Dashboard
├── Overview
│   ├── Total AI traffic (7-day, 30-day)
│   ├── AI traffic % of total
│   └── AI conversion rate
│
├── Platform Breakdown
│   ├── Traffic by AI source
│   ├── Engagement by platform
│   └── Conversion by platform
│
├── Content Performance
│   ├── Top pages from AI traffic
│   ├── AEO-optimized vs. standard
│   └── Schema type performance
│
└── Trends
    ├── AI traffic over time
    ├── Citation frequency trends
    └── Competitive position changes

GA4 Exploration Reports

Build custom explorations for AEO analysis.

Setup explorations for:

• AI traffic funnel analysis (landing → engagement → conversion)
• Cohort analysis (AI visitors returning over time)
• Path analysis (AI traffic navigation patterns)

Attribution Setup

Configure attribution to credit AI traffic appropriately.

Multi-Touch Attribution

AI often assists conversions completed through other channels.

Configuration considerations:

• Include AI referrals in attribution models
• Test different attribution windows
• Compare first-touch vs. last-touch for AI traffic

Conversion Value Assignment

Assign values to AI-driven conversions for ROI calculation.

Implementation:

1. Define conversion values in GA4
2. Apply to AI traffic segments
3. Calculate cost-per-citation for AEO investment ROI

Testing Your Setup

Verify tracking works before relying on data.

Validation Checklist

Component	Test Method	Expected Result
AI referral detection	Visit from AI link	Appears in AI channel
Custom events	Trigger event manually	Event appears in realtime
Segments	Apply to historical data	Reasonable numbers
Dashboard	Review all visualizations	Data populates correctly

Common Setup Errors

Issues to check:

• Filters excluding AI traffic accidentally
• Channel grouping priority incorrect
• Event names inconsistent between implementation and GA4
• Segment definitions too narrow or broad

Maintenance Schedule

Analytics setup requires ongoing maintenance.

Monthly tasks:

• Verify AI source patterns still accurate (platforms add new domains)
• Check custom event firing rates
• Update dashboards with new metrics

Quarterly tasks:

• Review and update channel groupings
• Audit tracking implementation on key pages
• Validate attribution model performance

Key Takeaways

Set up AEO analytics systematically:

1. Configure GA4 first - Create AI channel groupings and segments
2. Implement custom events - Track AEO-specific interactions beyond pageviews
3. Integrate Search Console - Correlate AI visibility with branded search
4. Use specialized tools - Fill gaps with dedicated monitoring platforms
5. Build actionable dashboards - Surface insights that drive decisions
6. Maintain ongoing - Update tracking as platforms and patterns change

Analytics setup transforms AEO from guesswork to data-driven optimization. Invest time in proper configuration to measure what matters.

---

Related Articles:

• AEO Optimization Metrics: What to Track and Why (2026)
• AEO Optimization Software: Best Tools Compared (2026)
• What Is AEO? Answer Engine Optimization Explained
• AEO Implementation: 6-Month Roadmap and Timeline